Panhandlers

Every day, on my way to the bus stop, I pass a coffee shop. A panhandler has made that her spot. She sits outside there every morning. Sometimes she’s crying. Sometimes she’s curled up into a little ball. She’s a little younger than me, probably no older than 24, and dressed in decent clothes. Unlike other panhandlers, she doesn’t usually have a bag, or any stuff with her. She’s as skinny as hell, and her face is weirdly gaunt. I’ve spent time with people who have starved themselves, and her face isn’t like theirs. Their faces are gaunt and skull-like, but hers seems different. I wish I could explain how. Everytime I walk by her, I wonder if there’s anything I can do for her. Everytime I walk by, I wonder a little less.

This morning, there were two affluent looking middle aged ladies talking to the panhandler. They spoke quietly. She wailed her responses. I couldn’t hear what they said but, her answers were pretty clear. She kept saying that she just wanted to go home. She said that home was Toronto, and that she just wanted to go home.

I’ve never known how to deal with panhandlers. When I was growing up in Halifax, there were about half a dozen regular panhandlers downtown. I didn’t know them by name, but I recognized them. At one time or another, they all seemed messed up in some way: either talking to people who weren’t there, yelling and hitting themselves, or staring into space. I didn’t know what to do for them, so I gave them money. I thought that if I were ever mentally ill, and alone, I would need money. So I gave them the leftovers of my allowance.

Now I’m an adult living in Ottawa. And I still don’t how to deal with these people. They want my money. But I see many of them stumbling around downtown drunk or high. I don’t want to give them money. I don’t think it will help them. I’m afraid that money would just speed them on their way to an overdose.

As I got on the bus this morning, I saw the panhandler burst into tears and curl up in fetal position. The two middle aged ladies stood looking at her for a few moments, and then walked away.

When I got onto the bus, there was a copy of the Metro sitting in the empty seat. On the local news page there was a story about Terry Kilrea, one of Ottawa’s mayoral candidates. Yesterday he pledging that, if elected, he would hire another 78 police officers, and run the “vagrants” out of downtown. I don’t think that would help.

Those women turned their backs on the panhandler, and now one of our mayoral hopefuls wants our city to do the same thing.

9 Responses to “Panhandlers”

  1. 2006.Jul.23 @ 20:50

    Running “vagrants” out of town seems to me like the easy way out. But really where are these people going to go. The way I see it, there are probably 2 types of pan handlers. Mentally ill people how need help in to get off the streets, and the “lazy” who I would assume are the ones going around drunk or high. There may be other catagories and I’m sure that some people fit into a bit of both. Anyways, I think alot of people figure that all the panhandlers are just lazy.

    That being said, if we push them out of the city, the lazy will figure something out. But the ones that really need our help will be the ones that suffer.

    A better solution? I don’t know. Does anyone?

    An interesting note, 2 hours before the photos of people swiming in trevi fountian, there was 2 gypsys stealing all the coins before the security from across the street ran out and blew whistels at them. This is an ancient problem that no one seems to have a practical solutions to.

  • 2006.Jul.24 @ 10:33

    Mentioning the mentally ill raises a good point. I moved to Ottawa in 1995. At that time, there were relatively few panhandlers. Since then, it seems like the number of panhandlers has grown.

    I’m not sure what happened between then and now, but I am under the impression that the government of the day went about closing mental hospitals, and reducing the number of in-community half-way houses. Which suggests a solution: reopen those hospitals and halfway houses.

    e

  • 2006.Jul.24 @ 11:16

    I don’t know if I’d say that there are only 2 types. I do feel that some of the panhandlers are truly trying to get back on their feet but for one reason or another (say a teenager from an abusive home or even an older person who has fallen on hard times and has nobody to turn to). Some of the homeless will do odd jobs from time to time but on days where there is nothing for them to do, panhandling at least puts a little money in their pockets.

    But every time I think that I remember the “stories” people have about panhandlers talking on their cellphones or going home to shower before going out drinking with their friends. I’m also reminded of the news report I was watching where they were interviewing two teens living under a bridge when one of their teens got a call on her cell phone. It was her parents checking in with her. She said she got along with her parents and everything but she just decided she wanted to live under a bridge with her boyfriend.

    I’m in favour of e’s suggestion of reopening hospitals and halfway houses. Giving them somewhere to go for help is a good start. But you also need to make sure that it doesn’t become a “crutch” and that it’s used by people who need it (hopefully only for a short time until they get back on their feet). Because I’d be all for helping out the 15 year-old who’s been abused by her parents but a little less inclined to help out the 15 year-old who left her loving parents because she wanted to be with her boyfriend.

  • 2006.Jul.25 @ 16:45

    I’m sure I over simplified when saying that there is only 2 types of pan handlers. Or maybe I should have just broke it down to people who need help and people who need to get a job.

    Darrells case of the two 15 year olds is perfect. One of them need help and we should do everything we can to help them. The other needs a kick in the ass.

  • 2006.Jul.25 @ 16:57

    I think the kick in the ass probably comes naturally out of living on the street. It sounds like a pretty hard life. A good indication of that comes from the panhandlers I see on Bank street.

    There are two groups: regulars and transients. The regulars have been around for a year or two. I recognize a lot of them. They usually look like they’ve lived a pretty rough life (gaunt, stooped, glazed eyes). They’re usually begging alone. Those are the folks that beg for money during the winter. I’ve seen a number of them in various states of fuck-up-edness: passed out, drunk, high. If they weren’t mentally ill before living on the street, they’re probably pretty messed up now.

    The transients are usually younger. They are sometimes in pairs. They look a lot healthier. I see them for a few weeks or months, and then they disappear.

    There aren’t a lot of regulars. Maybe a dozen in Centretown, if that.

    e

  • 2006.Jul.26 @ 14:13

    Are you suggesting that the ones that have somewhere else to go eventually smarten up and go there?

    MG

  • 2006.Jul.26 @ 15:35

    MG,

    Sort of. I’m suggesting that they disappear somewhere. I hope they aren’t just moving along to the next city, but it’s possible. After that kid was murdered near the Rideau Centre, the CBC interviewed a few other kids living down there. They all said they had been on the streets for less than a year. I’m assuming that most people eventually decide that they don’t want to live that way, and get out. At least I hope that’s the case.

    e

  • 2007.Jan.08 @ 20:09

    DO NOT GIVE MONEY!!
    no matter what the case, handing money to a stranger you dont know is wrong. Maybe your helping and maybe your not. you arent qualified to make that desion.
    If you dont give them money they will be forced to go home or seek goverment help and receive the treatment required as determined by a proffessional workers assigned to their case!
    We pay taxes and thats one of the things we pay for.
    force them to seek help that will actually help them!

  • 2007.Apr.09 @ 15:39

    I agree with “DO NOT GIVE MONEY”. Buy a coffee or a happy meal, give them a coat that was destined for the Salvation Army.

    A person was recounting an incident recently that happened at his rural home. He had noticed a fox venturing near his house. He put some leftovers out, and before long, the fox was eating out of his hand. One morning he went out and was greeted by 3 foxes, thus he had created a “Fox PROBLEM”! The moral of this story is simple. As long as people give money, these beggars will not go away, will not change their life.

    Since October of 2006 there is this person, about 40 years of age. He has been sitting in strategic spots within the city of Thunder Bay. He sits near the street, where traffic sees him clearly, close to driveways that lead to financial institutions. He sits on city property and is very well aware of city by laws and property laws. He has a sign that asks for “HELP” and indicates that there are “no jobs”. On most days, he has a dog with him. They seem to be comfortable as he has blankets and sleeping bags to keep warm. He is out there every day, seven days a week, no matter what the weather, rain snow or sleet. In October, on rainy days, he had an umbrella. During the winter when we had minus 40 windchills, he had a heavy coat and braved the cold in his usual 4 to 5 hours sitting there. He seems to be in good health, as he walks to and from this spot every day, carrying a big back pack of his gear, and his dog on a leash.

    I see him every day, as I drive to and from work. I have seen people handing him money, and then petting his dog. He looks like a very intelligent person as he knows where to sit, what to do and what not to do.

    When I first saw him I had sympathy for him, and if I happened to be walking by or attending to business at the bank or grocery store, I would surely have stopped and given him money. I thought he was a transient down on his luck and was trying to go home to another town or province. I have since learned that he lives in an apartment with a woman and some other dogs, and that he has at least 2 other places where he sits, again close to financial institutions.

    In this case, it is hard not to assume that he is NOT in need, and that he simply has been spoiled by this lifestyle which is probably giving him a good buck. If he is getting $5.00 from 10 people a day, this is $350.00 a week, about $1,500.00 a month, a darn good supplement to any Ontario Works cheque or pension.

    What did that rural home owner do to get rid of the problem with the foxes? He stopped feeding them.

    How will we get that guy to get off his ass and find meaningful employment? STOP GIVING HIM MONEY.

    Some people really do need help. It is important that we know how to differentiate. It is also important that we realize there are Social Safety Nets.

    Vince
    Thunder Bay

  • Reply

    You can use these HTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    If your website is claim enabled, it will be notified that you have posted here.