MMP? Yeah, you know me.

Those of you who visit the PiePalace website may have noticed the Vote For MMP bling in the right hand column. I’m voting for Mixed Member Proportional representation because:

  1. I want to see smaller parties in Ontario’s legislature. In the last provincial election, the Greens got 2.8% of the vote (that’s 126,651 votes) but no seats1. Meanwhile, the Liberals got 46% of the vote with 2,090,001 votes. On average each Liberal seat cost 29,028 votes. Even though the Greens got more than four times that, we didn’t get a single seat.
  2. I want to be able to vote separately for local representative and the party of my choice. So far I’ve been happy with my Green Party candidates, but it’s possible that another party would field a candidate that I prefer. In that situation, I don’t want to have to hold my nose and vote for a candidate I don’t like.
  3. I’m tired of seeing false majorities. During the last election, the Liberals received only 46% of the vote, yet took 70% of the seats. I would much rather see a coalition government that included a number of parties.

There’s an interesting swirl of activity going on around the MMP campaign. The Yes side seems to be relatively well organized: their website looks pretty snazzy, and it has a pretty well written explanation of why MMP is good. Meanwhile, the No side seems to be relying on fear, uncertainty, and doubt.

Footnotes
  1. All numbers from Wikipedia. The Elections Ontario website wasn’t serving historic data when I wrote this post. (back)

5 Responses to “MMP? Yeah, you know me.”

  1. 2007.Aug.19 @ 16:43

    The Greens would have to up their vote by .2% to get their seats in the proposed MMP style. But they should have no trouble based on how they poll in ON.

  • 2007.Aug.19 @ 19:29

    I support MMP because the voters will get a legislature that represents them. If the Greens get 3% of the vote, then they deserve around 4 seats. If the Liberals get 40% of the vote, they deserve around 40% of the seats.

    One must not assume that the NDP will be in every coalition. The Liberals and Conservatives can form a coalition if the NDP seems unreasonable with the other parties.

  • 2007.Aug.21 @ 13:23

    Skinny Dipper: I tend to agree. The big three parties in Ontario have enough common ground that I could see coalitions forming between any mix of NDP, Conservatives, or Liberals.

  • 2007.Aug.21 @ 14:56

    What’s the point of having a Green member in Queen’s Park!

    How many opposition bills ever get passed? How many committees are chaired by opposition MPPs or allow the opposition to make up the majority of a committee? The answer is 0! Instead of wasting are time electing MPPs, we should be concentrating our time reforming the various processes in the Ontario Legislature that effectively bar any opposition introduced legislation from ever making it to the floor and debated, let alone made into law.

    How about having the Committee Chairs proportionally represented!

  • 2007.Aug.21 @ 23:14

    Hi Ken,

    You’re right. We should reform the Ontario Legislature, which is precisely why I’m voting in favour of MMP. As you say, there’s more to be done, but MMP is a good start.

    e

  • Reply

    You can use these HTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    If your website is claim enabled, it will be notified that you have posted here.