Why bother?

The Canadian blogosphere has been buzzing about three cops trying to throw stones at the SPP protest in Montebello.1 It seems quite likely that the three gents in question were involved with the cops: at the first sign of trouble they fled into the waiting arms of the Sûreté du Québec; and their boots were identical to those of the Sûreté.

I’m left to wonder about the motive. Why would the RCMP/Sûreté/CSIS bother to dress a few of their own up as protesters? One of them was carrying a rock, so we can guess that they were going to try and throw it at the police line. I can only guess why the RCMP/Sûreté/CSIS would want to do that:

  • The threat of violence justifies a large police presence,
  • It would make the opponents of the SPP look more like whack-jobs and less like people with something to say,
  • It would give grounds for the police/government to limit protests in future.

But all of those reasons seem so Machiavellian. They seem motivations of a police force desperate to justify its budget, or a government that really is afraid of a “sad” protest with “only” 1,200 attendees.

The only way to get to the bottom of this is to find out who ordered the provocateurs into the protest, and ask them why it was so necessary to smear a legitimate expression of public concern.

Footnotes
  1. For those who don’t know, Canada’s main man Stephen Harper is meeting with George Bush and Mexico’s President Felipe Calderon to chat about further integration of North American security forces and economies. (back)

6 Responses to “Why bother?”

  1. Pingback from University Update – Michael Bloomberg – Why bother?
  • 2007.Aug.23 @ 09:20

    The link to the picture of their boots didn’t work for me so I just wanted to post other sites you can see it at:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKyeemaGnv4&NR=1

    Or in better resolution:
    http://cupe.ca/gallery/albums/montebello-Monday/Montebello_20_ao_t_050.sized.jpg

  • 2007.Aug.23 @ 09:22

    Sorry, I messed up the second link (I put a capital ‘M’).
    http://cupe.ca/gallery/albums/montebello-monday/Montebello_20_ao_t_050.sized.jpg

  • 2007.Aug.23 @ 16:45

    You know I was gonna come in here and say that it was crap, that some matching boots didn’t make them cops. That and that the link was dead.

    But 2 guys where the same boots as one of the cops is a little suspicious.. Which leaves you with the question of why? What on earth would they hope to achive with pulling crap like that?

    I don’t think that it to justify the large police presence. Had this happened in a city someone would have thrown rocks. So even if you aren’t in the city you need the presence of the police.

    Maybe to make them look like wack jobs. I don’t think they want to start limiting protests. That will probably draw more attention than the protests themselves.

    Maybe there were just some bad apples from the cops side who wanted to band some heads together.. Who knows… Unless some reporter manages to identify one of the guys we’ll never know.

  • 2007.Aug.23 @ 23:56

    Ok, so no big surprise, the news is now saying that they were cops. But officials are claiming that they were just trying to identify potentially violent people. So why was one carrying a rock?

  • 2007.Sep.21 @ 08:35

    Late comment on this, but I don’t think this behavior is at all surprising, and I doubt this was a top down decision. These are the fruits of secrecy: when the various levels of an organization think that they can act without oversight or public scrutiny with the excuse of secrecy for the public good, Bad Things happen.

  • Reply

    You can use these HTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    If your website is claim enabled, it will be notified that you have posted here.